MLB RT. June 24th 2013.

Welcome to the MLB Roundtable! Today we break out the battery of Archie and Steve to talk closers, All-Stars, Division winners and who is the biggest surprise so far!

MLB1. How important is a Great Closer to a team compared to having a Staff Ace starter?

ARCHIE: To answer this question you only have to look at the perennial play-off teams. It is the exception and not the norm that a team makes it to the playoffs closing by committee. Every team has their “Ace” or number one starter. Granted that some are more Ace than others. But not every team has that exceptional closer. Those teams that do however, seem to make the playoff run every year.

STEVE: Say no more than Mariano Rivera. Perhaps the greatest closer that ever played the game. He was probably responsible for a few of the Yankees World Championships. As a former pitcher myself, I can say with certainty that closing is one of the hardest jobs. If you get into a jam, you don’t have another inning to make up for it as a starter. I think having a strong closer is essential to a winning baseball program. That being said, I do not want to take anything away from starters. It takes a strong starting rotation to win in a short series, the reason a closer is pivotal is because if you are in 2-1 game in the ninth inning, and your starter pitched his heart out. That closer has to have the mentality to go out there and finish that game for his starting pitcher. Its not easy.

2. Early look at the ASG candidates. List your AL All-Stars.

ARCHIE: cather, Joe Mauer, 1st base, Chris Davis, 2nd base, Robinson Cano, 3rd base, Miquel Cabrera (and there’s not a close second), SS, Jonny Peralta, OF, Mike Trout, Adam Jones, Nelson Cruz.

STEVE: Tough because there are the players who SHOULD get in to the players that WILL get in. My All Stars that SHOULD be there are as follows: 1B Chris Davis- Baltimore  2B Robinson Cano- NY Yankees  3B Miguel Cabrera (though Longoria will get in as a reserve) SS JJ Hardy- Baltimore  C  Joe Mauer- Minnesota, Outfield Mike Trout- LA Angels, Jose Bautista- Toronto, Adam Jones- Baltimore

3. Who wins AL East this year?

ARCHIE: This is the ONLY division in MLB that every team is currently ABOVE the .500 mark. Again, they are proving to be the best division in MLB. And, at this point in the season, I’m liking the Orioles to squeak out the crown.

STEVE: Very tough call on this, I think the team that is playing the best baseball at the end of the year will take it. Look for this to be a race to the finish with all five teams in the hunt. I think the injuries are going to hurt the Yankees down the stretch so they are on the outside looking in, Tampa is not consistent this season and will not keep pace. So that leaves the Red Sox, Orioles, and Blue Jays. The Toronto Blue Jays are starting to play the way they are supposed to. I see the Jays coming out on top as I think they will play the best baseball over the next three months of the season and take the division by 2 games. Have no fear Baltimore and Boston fans, there still are two wild card spots that will likely be taken by your teams. Toronto edges out the East.

4. Who wins the NL West this year?

ARCHIE: Only the Dodgers have rode off into the sunset. Or at least seem to have. They still have the talent to make a run, but I’m thinking they will have players on the sellers market before the 31 July deadline. The rest of the division have only a margin of 3.5 games after this weekend separating top and 4th place. I still think the Giants have the best rotation to shut teams down, so I will give the nod to the SF Giants to finish the season in first in the west.

STEVE: Lets break it down just like I did the AL East. The Dodgers are done so we eliminate them right off the bat. The Rockies have been playing good baseball all year, but I don’t see them keeping pace in the west. The Padres have been a surprise to some, and I think they are the wild card here, as I can’t seem to put them over the top, nor can I write them off. This leaves the Giants and Diamondbacks. The Diamondbacks are clicking on all cylinders, they have a solid pitching staff, great hitting, and solid defense, and a fundamentally sound manager in Kirk Gibson. The Giants have spurts of greatness and at times look like the team that ran through the playoffs last season, however there are periods where they cant score a run. I give the Diamondbacks a slight edge here, but you cannot count out the defending champs.

5. What team will be the biggest surprise for the rest of the year? Pittsburgh Pirates

ARCHIE: Remember in September, you heard it here first. The PIRATES make the playoffs this year. I really like the team Huntington has put together and the team is playing good ball. I am not sure they will win their Division, after all they have a lot to overcome against St Louis and Cincinnati, but they WILL NOT fold like a cheap lawn chair this season. In fact, they just might be one of those teams looking to pick up some of that overpriced Dodger talent before the deadline.

STEVE: After seeing what the Pirates did against the Angels on Sunday night, it is hard to not pick them. However, I am not that surprised at what they have accomplished this season, and I think it will continue into the playoffs for the Bucs. The team that will surprise a few people? I have to go with the Toronto Blue Jays. Okay, maybe not the biggest surprise, but you have to take a look at how they started the season to how they are playing currently. Why will this be a surprise? Because I am predicting that from now until the playoffs, the Blue Jays will own the best record in baseball. This team is finally starting to play the level of baseball that the management signed. RA Dickey will come back to form, Buerhle will have a better second half, and Josh Johnson will return to his old form. If they can get Jose Reyes back (which is not likely) they will be in the drivers seat and go all the way to the top of the East by the end of the year.



Tiny URL for this post:



About Archie 139 Articles
Name: Archie Michael Williams Age: 57 (as of 17 September) Occupation: Department of the Army Civilian / Retired Army NCO Grew up in North Carolina, now live in Oklahoma I entered the US Army in October 1984 and retired May 2005. Veteran of the Gulf War with the 3rd Armor Calvary Regiment (ACR) Spent entire Army career as a Fire Support Specialist (Field Artillery Observer / Coordinator) Avid, let me say this again, AVID sports fan. Favorite teams and sports: NFL = Pittsburgh Steelers MLB = Atlanta Braves NBA = OKC Thunder NHL = There is no way I could care less. Soccer = see NHL note College NCAAF = Oklahoma Sooners NCAAB = UNC Tarheels. Hobbies = Golf, Bowling , Hunting, Fishing I will answer any questions you have, Just give me a buzz!

1 Comment

  1. Steve: I have to disagree with your assessment of the Jays and how they will finish this season.
    Specifically, in regards to your thinking about Dickey and Buerhle, i.e. neither of these two pitchers will be anything special from here until the season ends. In fact, in my opinion, while they may wind up with a winning W/L pct they will do so by only a few games at the most. Which makes either of them a 3 or 4 in the Jays’rotation when the Jays need them to be a 2 and a 2A.
    And Johnson may actually (as you indicated) return to his old form but I am willing to bet that he misses a start or two to some nagging injury or another as the season progresses. Or, maybe even gets a trip to the DL which will really not do the Jays’ fortunes any good at all.
    I do agree with your thought that Reyes will essentilly be a nonfactor in the Jays season, however.
    The bottom line is that the Jays made a nice recent run but will fade to the middle of the pack and miss the playoffs because they just do not have the necessary pitching.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.